January 2, 2004
Another New Years' resolution
Because I'm not taking a formal mathematics class this semester, I've written a resolution that says I will read through G.H. Hardy's A Course of Pure Mathematics and do all the exercises. I'm already finding (what I think are) mistakes. Here's a selection from page 5:If the length PQ, along a given line, is a, and the length QR, along the same straight line, is b, the length PR must be (a+b).To which I say,
I suppose that if you allow for negative lengths, then the rule still applies, but I've never heard of a negative length before. (For you physics freaks out there, yes, you can have a negative displacement, but this is a length, goddamnit.) I'm surprised to find what looks like a mistake in the tenth edition of a book that's supposed to be "formal and rigorous" (according to the Amazon reviewers). Perhaps it's because of a shift in terminology?
Posted by Jeffrey at January 2, 2004 7:12 PM
What is a TrackBack? Learn more here. TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.geekable.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/4
Listed below are links to the 0 weblogs that reference 'Another New Years' resolution' from Geekable.com.
http://www.geekable.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/4
Listed below are links to the 0 weblogs that reference 'Another New Years' resolution' from Geekable.com.


